Market positioning strategy: how to pick yours, with a template and real examples

By Zach Schleien

What a market positioning strategy is, the common types, 7 steps to build and test one, a fill-in template and examples from a dating app, a matchmaking business and a Slack community.

A market positioning strategy is your decision about who you're for, what you want to be the obvious choice for, and why a buyer should pick you over whatever they'd use instead. You boil it down to one or two sentences, then make your offer, your price, your landing page and your sales calls all say the same thing.

Most guides stop at a list of positioning types and a fill-in-the-blank template. That's a fine start. What decides whether it works is picking a position your real buyers agree with, and then testing it with money and time instead of opinions.

I've been building companies for 15 years, including a venture-backed dating app, a matchmaking business and a mental health community that grew to 18,000+ members. Below is how I'd build a positioning strategy from scratch, with the common types, a template and examples from my own companies.

Want help applying this to your business? Book a free strategy call.

Key takeaways

  • Positioning answers three questions: who it's for, what it's the best choice for, and why you instead of the alternative.
  • Start from who already buys from you and why, not from who you wish would buy.
  • Pick one main way to stand out, like price, quality, a niche, convenience or a different approach, and back it with proof.
  • Write it as one statement: For [who], who [problem], [product] is the [category] that [benefit]. Unlike [alternative], we [proof].
  • Test it with real buyers through ads, landing pages and sales calls. Surveys told me no on an offer that people then bought like crazy.

What market positioning means

Positioning is the spot you hold in a buyer's head next to their other options. When someone thinks "I need help with this," your positioning decides whether you come to mind, and for what.

It gets mixed up with a few other words:

  • Target market is who you sell to. Positioning includes that, plus why those people should pick you.
  • Branding is how you look and sound: your name, logo, colors and voice. Good branding makes a position easier to remember, but it can't fix a weak one.
  • Messaging is the actual words on your ads, site and sales calls. Messaging comes from positioning, not the other way around.
  • A tagline is a short public version of your position. When Filteroff launched on Product Hunt, the tagline was "Video speed dating app. Get to know the person, not the profile." In two short sentences it said what the app was and what made it different.

The common types of positioning strategies

Most positions fall into one of these buckets. You can combine two, but one should lead.

  1. Price. You're the cheapest option or the best value. This works when you can keep your costs lower than everyone else for a long time, which is hard for a small company.
  2. Premium or quality. You charge more because you deliver more. At Filteroff, we were one of the first dating apps to launch high-ticket human matchmaking, with packages of around $2,000 each.
  3. Niche. You serve one type of customer, one industry or one place better than anyone else. A narrow niche is usually the easiest position for a new company to win.
  4. Convenience. You're the fastest or easiest option. The buyer picks you because you save them time, steps or hassle.
  5. A different approach. You solve the same problem in a new way. Filteroff's version was video speed dating, so you got to know the person before you judged the profile.
  6. Customer type. The same product, positioned for a different buyer with a different problem. My 18percent example below shows how that works.
  7. Against a named alternative. You point at the option buyers already know and show, with a number, where you beat it.

How to build a market positioning strategy in 7 steps

1. Start with who already buys, and why

Look at the customers you already have before you look at the whole market. Who bought fastest? Who stayed longest? Who sent you referrals? What words did they use to describe their problem? If you want to write the answers down in one place, use a buyer persona template.

The best source is your own sales calls. Take the calls yourself until you understand the common objections and what your customers really want. When I let go of Filteroff's outsourced sales agencies and took the matchmaking calls myself, my close rate started around 20% and nearly doubled within 30 days. You hear exactly how buyers describe the problem, and that's the raw material for your position.

2. List the real alternatives

Your competition isn't only the companies that look like you. It's whatever the buyer would do if you didn't exist. That might be a bigger competitor, a cheaper tool, a spreadsheet, hiring someone or doing nothing at all.

For each alternative, write down what it does well and where it leaves the buyer stuck. That gap is where your position goes.

You can speed up this research with AI. When I helped my friend Ryan rebuild his ad-to-landing-page pipeline, we had Manus, an AI agent that does research, analyze all of his competitors before we rebuilt his landing page.

3. Pick the one thing you'll be known for

Choose the one difference that matters most to your best buyers and that you can prove. You can have a supporting point or two, but one difference should lead.

Then attach proof: a number, a result, a demo or a customer story. "More engaging" means nothing on its own. At Filteroff, average session length was 200 seconds versus Tinder's 110, nearly double. That's something a buyer, an investor or a journalist can repeat.

Want a Growth Roadmap for Your Startup?

Book a free 30-minute strategy call and get a tailored growth roadmap for your startup.

Book a Free Strategy Call

4. Decide where you sit on price

Price is part of your position whether you plan it or not. A low-priced app and a high-ticket service can solve the same problem for very different buyers.

Early Filteroff had low-ticket subscriptions at $9 to $25, and the rest of the ladder was missing. Looking back, I'd build all three levels from day one: low-ticket for people who want to do it themselves, mid-ticket (roughly $75 to $200) for "do it with us," and high-ticket for done for you. Same customer, different levels of support.

For a service business, I price tiers like an airplane: economy, business class and first class. I cap it at about three tiers, because more than that gives buyers too many choices. I also don't show premium prices on the page. I qualify the buyer first and share the price on the call.

And don't assume price is the reason people aren't buying. In matchmaking, some people sell $30,000 packages, and we sold an offer of around $2,000 over the phone. When an offer isn't selling, price is the last thing I'd suspect, not the first. Check your sales calls, your objection handling, your landing page and the offer itself before you discount.

5. Write your positioning statement

Here's a simple template:

For [who], who [problem], [product] is the [category] that [main benefit]. Unlike [main alternative], we [proof of the difference].

A made-up example for a small software company: "For independent dental offices that lose money on missed appointments, [Name] is the reminder service that refills cancelled slots the same day. Unlike a front desk calling down a list, it texts every patient on the waitlist at once."

Keep this statement internal. It's a decision tool for you and your team, not ad copy. Your tagline, headlines and sales script come from it later.

6. Test it with real buyers, not surveys

A few years into Filteroff, I emailed potential customers asking if they'd want matchmaking from us, and at what price. Almost everyone said no. I launched it anyway, with a thoughtful landing page and a video explaining how it worked. People bought like crazy, including the same people who had said no.

Surveys are useful after launch, when you ask buyers what's missing or what confused them. Before launch, test your position where people spend money or time:

  • Ads. Run two or three versions of your position as separate ads to the same audience, and compare the cost of a qualified lead.
  • Landing pages. Send the same traffic to two headlines and compare sign-ups.
  • Sales calls. Say the position out loud and listen. "That's exactly my problem" is a good sign. "So it's like that other company?" means your difference isn't landing.

Also test before you copy whatever your category does. On a campaign I ran for a real estate sponsor raising for a nine-figure project under Rule 506(c), objection-handling reels, the format most firms run, spent $1,600 across 7 ad sets and booked zero calls, while a plain founder asking directly booked calls in cold and warm audiences.

7. Make every asset say the same thing

Once a position wins a test, rewrite everything around it: your homepage headline, ads, offer, sales script, follow-up emails and bio. If your ads say premium and your page leads with a discount, buyers get confused and leave.

Your proof has to match the position too. Our matchmaking landing page converted at 15%. To lift it, I added logos, testimonials, a video above the fold and other conversion elements, because a high-ticket position needs trust a buyer can see. Here's what to put on a conversion landing page.

Market positioning examples from my own companies

18percent: one community, positioned for two buyers

18percent was a free private Slack community for people struggling with mental health, named for the roughly 18% of the U.S. population living with mental illness. It grew to 18,000+ members, the largest mental health community on Slack, with 3M+ messages.

For partners, the position was specific. Many people calling hotlines were lonely rather than in crisis, and 18percent gave them a community to go to, which freed up crisis phone lines. Crisis Text Line referred people directly, and the National Eating Disorders Association was also a partner.

For employers, I built a different pitch that positioned 18percent as a workplace mental health resource, anchored on the WHO statistic that unaddressed mental health costs $1 trillion per year in lost productivity. Nothing about the community changed between those two pitches. What changed was who I was talking to, the problem I led with and the proof I used.

Filteroff: narrowing the position until it worked

Filteroff pivoted four times over roughly 4.5 years, and each pivot was really a new position. It started as a global video speed dating app with 1-minute dates, later extended to 3 minutes. Then retention data showed that locals date locals, so we narrowed to New York City. NYC users went from 5,600 in February 2022 to 36,000 by year end, 542% growth in one year.

The fourth pivot was human matchmaking feeding into the dating pool, at around $2,000 per client. That position hit $50K in revenue in a single month, and it's the business that got acquired.

A new matchmaking business: building the offer around the position

Simone Grossman had nine years of matchmaking skill but no business of her own yet: no site, no funnel, no offers and no sales script. We built her offer and pricing together, and added offers underneath the high-ticket package. She did $22K in her first three weeks, and she's done $160K in about five months since launching.

If you're starting one yourself, here's how to start a matchmaking business, from the offer and price to your first clients.

Signs your positioning isn't working

  • Buyers ask "so it's like that other company?" and you spend the call explaining the difference.
  • Most objections are about price. When buyers can't see what makes you different, they compare you on the one thing they can see.
  • You attract the wrong leads. If most people on your sales calls aren't a fit, your ads and page are describing someone else.
  • Ads only work with a discount. Buyers are responding to the deal instead of to what makes you different.
  • Your team describes the company in different ways. If three people give three answers, buyers will hear three answers too.

When to change your positioning

Change it when your data tells you to, not because you're bored of it. Watch who stays, who refers others, who closes fastest and who churns. Filteroff narrowed to New York City because of retention data, not a hunch.

When you do change it, change everything at once: the ads, the page, the offer and the script. A new position with old messaging gives buyers two different stories, and that confuses them.

Frequently asked questions

What is a market positioning strategy?

It's your plan for how you want buyers to see you next to their other options: who you're for, what you're the best choice for, and why they should pick you. It's usually written as a one or two sentence positioning statement.

What are the main types of positioning strategies?

The common ones are price, premium or quality, niche, convenience, a different approach, customer type, and positioning against a named alternative. Most companies lead with one and support it with a second.

What's the difference between positioning and branding?

Positioning is the decision about who you're for and why you're the better choice. Branding is how you look and sound while you say it, like your name, logo, colors and voice.

How do you write a positioning statement?

Fill in this template: For [who], who [problem], [product] is the [category] that [main benefit]. Unlike [main alternative], we [proof of the difference]. Keep it internal and use it to write your headlines, ads and sales script.

How do you know if your positioning is working?

Test it where people spend money or time: ads, landing pages and sales calls. If the right buyers respond, objections move away from price and fewer people ask how you're different from a competitor, it's working.

Want a Growth Roadmap for Your Startup?

Book a free 30-minute strategy call and get a tailored growth roadmap for your startup.

Book a Free Strategy Call

About the Author

Written by Zach Schleien, founder of PressPitch AI. 200+ press features across 25 countries including the New York Times, Forbes, BBC, and Good Morning America. Previously co-founder and CEO of Filteroff (acquired by a major dating conglomerate).

More founder story and growth guides

See all